Stop hooking up with her and cut off contact with her
Continue hooking up with her and try to ignore the feelings you have for her, OR…
Stop hooking up with her and attempt to turn the relationship into a traditional boyfriend/girlfriend relationship
There are no right or wrong answers to this one. All I can do is give you advice and share with you how I have handled the situation in the past. Our emotions work in a funny way. They control how we think and act, so it’s hard for me to tell you what you should do because your heart will probably tell you something else and you will act on it.
Cut off contact with her: This is easily the most difficult thing to do. By doing this, you’re essentially giving your heart the middle finger. And even if you try this, how long will the no-contact last? Again, you’ve fallen for this chick, so not speaking to her at all is going to eat at you. But then again, if you stay in contact with her and continue sleeping with her, you’ll run into these problems…
Continue just having sex: Booty call relationships only last for so long. I think my longest was about 3 ½ months. Eventually, you’ll both go your separate ways unless it becomes a serious relationship. That’s going to be a hard pill to swallow. Plus, the more you have sex with her, the stronger your feelings for her will get. What I’m saying is this probably isn’t a smart idea.
Attempt to turn it into a traditional relationship: This one really doesn’t matter if she doesn’t feel the same about you. But even if she does, you have to take into consideration a few things. First off, it’s not common that a sex-first relationship leads to a long-term relationship. If sex is the only thing you do early on, the relationship becomes physical and that’s not a recipe for long-term success. Also, do you really want a relationship? If you’re certain you’re ready for one, go for it. But if you’re like me and enjoy being single more, DON’T DO IT!